PS Plus Extra games for May 2025 - Borderlands and EA FC 25 lead predictions

PS Plus Extra and Premium subscribers are just days away from finding out which new games will be joining the service for the month of May.

The next wave of Extra and Premium games will be officially revealed by on the afternoon of May 14. The and games will be available to download and play on May 20.

As we close in on the big reveal, some fans have been attempting to predict the line-up before Sony's announcement.

In the monthly predictions thread over on Reddit, multiple fans believe a Borderlands game could join PS Plus Extra.

With Borderlands 4 launching in September, fans speculate that publisher 2K may add a previous Borderlands game to help get players up to speed.

There are picks for Borderlands 3, as well as New Tales from the Borderlands and Borderlands Game of the Year Enhanced. With Sony recently holding a Borderlands 4 State of Play event, the relationship between Sony and 2K appears to be strong.

Another game with multiple picks is EA FC 25. The timing certainly makes sense, especially with the Premier League season coming to an end in May and sales starting to decline. If it doesn't join PS Plus Extra in May, then don't be surprised if it comes to PS Plus Essentials in June.

Other sports games are also tipped to appear in May, including NBA 2K25 which has multiple predictions and NHL 25 with just one pick.

Elsewhere, fans continue to predict Atomic Heart will join PS Plus Extra, alongside Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora, Until Dawn Remastered and Cuphead.

With the TV series in full swing, The Last of Us Part 2 has a few picks, as well as fellow first-party games such as LEGO Horizon, Horizon Forbidden West and Gran Turismo 7.

Other picks include Little Nightmares, Assassin's Creed Mirage, Lords of the Fallen, Resident Evil Village, Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty, Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden, Pacific Drive, GTA 5, Darkest Dungeon 2, Octopath Traveller, V Rising, One Piece, The Crew Motorsport, Spyro Trilogy, Story of Seasons A Wonderful Life, South Park Snow Day and The Quarry.

That's on top of Jusant, Indika, Sonic Superstars, Hitman, F1 Manager, Monster Hunter Stories, Scorn, Alone in the Dark, Still Wakes the Deep, Lies of P and Sekiro.

Some of the more unlikely predictions include Elden Ring, Final Fantasy 16, Star Wars Outlaws, Alan Wake 2 and Astro Bot.